← All episodes

Episode 41 · October 15, 2026 · 20:07

Rare By Design

High vertical wind shear and cool waters make South Atlantic hurricanes exceedingly rare. While climate-driven ocean warming lowers one barrier, atmospheric constraints persist, meaning rare storms like Hurricane Catarina may intensify rather than become frequent.

The Climate Translation podcast artwork

Episode summary

Rare By Design

High vertical wind shear and cool waters make South Atlantic hurricanes exceedingly rare. While climate-driven ocean warming lowers one barrier, atmospheric constraints persist, meaning rare storms like Hurricane Catarina may intensify rather than become frequent.

Key topics

  • Hurricanes are one of the central ideas explored in this episode.
  • Tropical climates are one of the central ideas explored in this episode.
  • Climate modeling is one of the central ideas explored in this episode.
  • Ocean warming is one of the central ideas explored in this episode.

Full text

Episode transcript

This transcript is provided so listeners can explore the science discussed in the episode in full context.

Introduction

If you plotted every tropical cyclone on a map of the world, a pattern would jump out almost immediately. The western Pacific is covered with storm tracks, as are the North Atlantic, the eastern Pacific, the Indian Ocean, and the waters surrounding Australia. But then you look at the South Atlantic. Across that entire basin, there is almost nothing. Since satellites began providing reliable global coverage, only one storm there has ever reached hurricane strength.

It developed in an ocean basin that normally maintains several built-in defenses against hurricanes: sea surface temperatures that are often too cool, persistent upper-level winds, and an atmospheric setup that does not regularly produce the tropical waves that seed storms elsewhere. So how did that lone hurricane manage to form? And as climate change warms the South Atlantic, could storms like it become less rare in the future? Welcome back to the podcast. I’m Dr. Mac, and this is The Climate Translation.

The Ocean That Says No

The stretch of water between South America and Africa—the tropical and subtropical South Atlantic—sits squarely in the tropics, yet it remains almost devoid of hurricanes. When we examine the physical ingredients required for tropical cyclogenesis, however, the absence of storms is not mysterious. Think of tropical cyclone formation like baking a cake: it requires a precise combination of flour, eggs, sugar, heat, and time. If even one critical ingredient is missing, the cake fails to rise.

Warm ocean water provides the primary thermodynamic fuel for tropical systems, but large sectors of the South Atlantic are cooler than tropical basins farther north. Along the eastern side of the basin, ocean currents and coastal upwelling bring relatively cold water toward the surface. Moisture is abundant, and the Coriolis force is sufficient away from the equator, but the basin lacks a dependable trigger. The North Atlantic benefits from a steady assembly line of disturbances during the boreal summer, driven by the strong thermal contrast between the Sahara and equatorial Africa that fuels the African Easterly Jet and its westward-moving African easterly waves. The South Atlantic has no equivalent atmospheric jet, and it generally lacks the broad convective band of the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ), leaving the basin with far fewer seedling disturbances to initiate rotation.

The greatest barrier of all, however, is vertical wind shear—the change in wind speed or direction with height through the troposphere. Imagine two children playing with wooden blocks: one child attempts to build a vertical tower, but the second child immediately reaches over and knocks the top blocks away. That is what hostile wind shear does to a developing tropical cyclone. Thunderstorms attempting to organize around a surface low are displaced downstream by strong upper-level winds, preventing the storm from stacking vertically and intensifying. Across the South Atlantic, environmental wind shear is routinely strong enough to disrupt organization. While a hurricane is not physically impossible in the basin, the necessary thermodynamic and dynamic ingredients almost never align in the same place at the same time. Yet in March 2004, the barriers briefly dropped, and the South Atlantic produced its first confirmed hurricane.

A Storm That Broke the Rules

In mid-March 2004, an ordinary extratropical low developed off the southeastern coast of Brazil. Extratropical cyclones derive their kinetic energy from horizontal temperature gradients across fronts, whereas tropical cyclones rely on deep warm-core structures sustained by latent heat released from ocean moisture. Occasionally, a non-tropical low can evolve into a warm-core tropical system through a process meteorologists call tropical transition, which is precisely what occurred off the Brazilian coast.

A large atmospheric blocking pattern established itself east of South America, acting like a persistent roadblock in the sky. This blocking high performed two critical roles: it halted the low's eastward exit across the open Atlantic, retrograding it toward the Brazilian coast, and it created an isolated pocket of remarkably weak vertical wind shear. For once, the disruptive upper-level winds subsided, allowing deep convection to organize symmetrically around the circulation center.

Thermodynamics provided another surprise. Sea surface temperatures beneath the system hovered around 25 degrees Celsius (77 degrees Fahrenheit)—below the classic 26.5°C (80°F) threshold often cited as the requirement for tropical cyclogenesis. However, convective instability depends on the vertical temperature gradient between the surface and the upper troposphere. An unusually cold pool of air in the upper atmosphere steepened lapse rates, generating sufficient convective available potential energy to sustain intense updrafts despite the marginal sea-surface temperatures. Over several days, frontal boundaries decayed, convection wrapped into a central dense overcast, a warm core formed, and satellites revealed a well-defined eye. On March 26, the system reached hurricane intensity, and on March 28, it made landfall in the Brazilian state of Santa Catarina with sustained winds near 95 miles per hour. Named Hurricane Catarina after its landfall location, the storm demonstrated that when atmospheric barriers temporarily collapse, the South Atlantic is physically capable of sustaining a hurricane.

Warming the Forbidden Ocean

Because hurricanes draw energy from the sea and global warming is heating the oceans, it is tempting to conclude that the South Atlantic will see more hurricanes. But climate change does not alter only the sea surface; it changes atmospheric thermodynamics and dynamics simultaneously. Researchers have investigated this exact question using another transitional storm: Subtropical Cyclone Anita, which developed off Brazil in March 2010.

In 2019, atmospheric scientists led by Michelle Reboita at the Federal University of Itajubá simulated Anita using numerical models. When they ran a sensitivity experiment by warming sea surface temperatures by 2°C across the basin while keeping the atmosphere constant, Anita completed a full tropical transition into a tropical cyclone. The increased sea-surface warmth enhanced latent and sensible heat fluxes, intensifying core convection and lowering central pressure. However, in 2021, a study led by Ryohei Nakamura at Niigata University placed Anita into a comprehensive late-century climate projection that warmed both the ocean and the atmosphere, while incorporating modeled shifts in humidity, pressure, and winds.

Under that realistic scenario, the intensification was significantly muted. Because the upper troposphere warms alongside the ocean, the vertical temperature lapse rate does not steepen as dramatically, counteracting some of the thermodynamic boost provided by warmer surface water. While full-climate simulations indicated that subtropical storms might still achieve slightly higher intensities and transition somewhat more readily, the models did not project the South Atlantic transforming into an active hurricane basin. Evaluating a basin with virtually no baseline hurricane activity remains challenging, but the findings highlight that a warmer ocean alone is not enough to override hostile atmospheric shear and stability.

Rare Doesn’t Mean Impossible

Hurricane Catarina remains the only confirmed hurricane in modern South Atlantic history, but a handful of tropical and subtropical storms have appeared since: Tropical Storm Anita in 2010, Tropical Storm Iba in 2019, and Tropical Storm Akará in February 2024. Akará originated along a decaying frontal zone, developed a warm-core structure, and sustained tropical storm-force winds hundreds of miles off the Brazilian coast. These systems confirm that tropical transition remains a viable physical pathway in the basin, even if fully developed hurricanes remain exceedingly rare.

Global climate model projections consistently show that while the proportion of high-intensity tropical cyclones (Categories 4 and 5) and associated rainfall rates are likely to increase globally, overall storm frequency may remain steady or even decrease. In the South Atlantic specifically, high-resolution modeling of future climate scenarios does not show a meaningful increase in the frequency of tropical transitions. The structural barriers—strong environmental wind shear, the absence of an easterly wave track, and unfavorable broad-scale circulation—remain largely intact even in a warmer world.

The primary concern, therefore, is not a dramatic surge in storm frequency, but the potential intensity of rare events when the atmospheric setup does align. A storm that transitions over warmer waters and reaches the coast in a higher sea-level environment carries elevated risks. Sea level along the South American coastline continues to rise, providing a higher launching pad for coastal inundation. A Catarina-strength storm occurring in the future would push storm surge farther inland than it did in 2004, simply because baseline sea levels are higher. Climate change alters the available energy and the background state of the coast, ensuring that even the rarest meteorological anomalies carry greater consequences.

Conclusion

The South Atlantic remains one of the least hospitable environments on Earth for tropical cyclones. Most of the time, the required atmospheric and oceanic ingredients simply do not align. But Hurricane Catarina demonstrated that rare does not mean impossible.

As the oceans warm, the thermodynamic potential of the basin is evolving. Whether that shift will ever produce another Catarina remains an open scientific question, but when the South Atlantic does occasionally lower its defenses, the energy waiting in the system will be greater than before.

I’m Dr. Mac. This has been The Climate Translation. If you have a question about the climate that you’ve been too afraid to ask, or if you have a differing opinion, I want to hear from you. I can use your viewpoints in a future episode. You can reach me at TheClimateTranslation@gmail.com. I’ll see you next time.